Cory Doctorow at Boing Boing:
The TSA's [No-Fly list and secondary screening lists] contain people who are dead. They contain the presidents of foreign countries. They contain incredibly common names like "Robert Johnson." These farcical lists are supposed to secure the skies, and the way they're supposed to do it is by denying air travel to thousands of innocent people (without catching a guilty person smart enough to use a fake ID). Even worse, because the gargantuan lists have to be widely circulated, the CIA won't allow the names of actual terrorist suspects to be added to them -- in other words, the No Fly lists only contain the names of people who aren't under any serious suspicion.
On the other hand, 14 of the 19 9/11 hijackers are on the list, in case they come back as zombies. (And if anyone makes a movie about zombies on planes, I want a writing credit.)
Seriously, the No Fly lists and programs like CAPPS II/Secure Flight are worse than useless because they waste resources and create a false sense of security. They also illustrate how the United States' technological strength can also be a weakness. We're very good at databases and networks, so we default to using them instead of training people to spot and thwart attacks. This is much like how our intelligence agencies rely on sigint and spectacularly fail in human spying and analysis. We prefer the illusion of electronic certainty to the messiness of human intelligence.
Recent Comments